Improving Decision-Making Through Games

91G+CYJsI9L._SL1500_.jpg

By: Ilhan Akcay

War games are a great way to learn about history and warfare on all levels in a simple, low-cost, easy to setup environment. This article and the attached listing present a few war games, placed into four categories that I‘ve found extremely useful for self-study.

Professional military education is a continuous process that doesn’t end at command. When you stop learning, you stop being relevant. A leader’s limited time and the high demands of this profession make it hard to find opportunities to learn on the job. The junior officer or NCO looking to improve his tactical skills has to do it on their own time. Another problem is how we make decisions. Formalized military decision-making is designed for staff work, is time consuming, and ill-suited for the tactical environment.[1]

War games are a great tool to hone intuitive decision making. The Prussians starting using war games in the 19th c. to prepare for conflicts against the Danish, Austrians, French, and Allied Powers in WWI. The UK Western Approaches Tactical Unit (WATU) used war games to counter German submarine operations in the Atlantic and protect convoys.[2] The US Navy used war games to plan the Pacific campaign in WWII.[3]

These organizations had the benefit of time, space, and resources in their simulations. The same benefits are often unavailable to the motivated officer or NCO who wants to study and practice in his free time. Fortunately, the civilian market offers a myriad of computer and board games that serve this very purpose. Indeed, commercially available war games often do a better job of simulating war than those designed by the military.[4]

Commercial war games are cost-efficient compared to military equivalents. Most war games cost between 80-250€ ($30-$300 in US Stores). Considering they provide insight, learning, professional development, and entertainment potentially for years, this is inexpensive. They are also convenient, with most games fitting into a small box. They can be quickly set up and left during breaks. Finally, they can be applied in a very specialized way, to simulate different levels of war and different situations, teaching tailored lessons every use.

Computer vs. Tabletop Games

The greatest discriminator for war games is between computer-based and tabletop-based games. Both fulfill a different purpose and can be complementary. Computer war games are great at simulating the fog of war and the command environment that a military leader faces. Computer games’ weakness is a tendency for micromanagement and too much detail.

Tabletop war games, on the other hand, are good for studying situations in-depth and top-down. This allows for a greater focus on behaviors and outcomes, emphasizing the human dimension of war just as much as the technological aspect. Board games also require us to learn a system of rules, providing the gamer insights into war and competition from the start.

Playing Through War

War games can be used to simulate different levels of war: tactics, operational art, and strategy. War games are a great way to learn about history by doing rather than just reading. That’s a unique experience, as players come to understand why things happened the way they did by facing the same dilemmas as the decision makers of the period.

The attached primer examines several war games useful for self-study, organized by area of learning (e.g. history, tactics, operational art, or strategy). Ideally, these games are best against an experienced human opponent, but are playable alone as well. These games have helped me learn about the conduct of war and provide understanding of how events transpired and why leaders made the decisions they did.

Improved knowledge of the complexities of war will lead to enhanced understanding of history and current events, and serve as a warning that bloody, complex war is best left to the board game, and avoided in the real world.

Let me know what you think of the games I chose. Are there other games you’ve played that helped you learn and improve your own decision making?

Click here to download Ilhan’s list of suggested war games for the strategic, operational, and tactical levels of war

Ilhan Akcay majored in aerospace engineering before he found his passion being a German paratrooper. He is interested in mission command and tactics, as well as cultural awareness and COIN. He runs the German based mil-blog School of War

[1] In the paper [How We Decide http://www.au.af.mil/au/awc/awcgate/usmc/schmitt_how_we_decide.pdf] Major John F. Schmitt (USMC) states “the Corps’ focus on analytical decisionmaking in its schools leaves Marines ill-prepared for leading in the real world.” He argues that decisionmakers use the analytical approach (formal MDMP) less than 10% of the time and trust their gut for the rest. He concludes “the Marine Corps must start to develop intuitive decision making skills among its leaders.”

[2] WATU performed well and could serve as an example for any military on how to conduct proper study of tactics and then translate it into actionable lessons learned, [https://paxsims.files.wordpress.com/
2017/12/2017-12-10-watu-mors.pdf]

[3] Admiral Nimitz commented in 1960,“During the war, the war with Japan had been re-enacted in the game rooms here by so many people and in so many different ways that nothing that happened during the war was a surprise—absolutely nothing except the kamikaze tactics towards the end of the war; we had not visualized those.”

[4] As researcher Philip Sabin notes in his book Simulating War https://www.amazon.com/Simulating-War-Studying-Conflict-Simulation-ebook/dp/B00LUUAENW

5 Comments

Filed under Leadership

5 responses to “Improving Decision-Making Through Games

  1. No “Axis and Allies”??? I’m not sure how valid this list is without that!
    Great post Ihan; interesting topic and game recommendations. Thanks for sharing.

    • Thank you sir!
      I never played Axis & Allies, that’s why I didn’t include it. When I was starting out with wargaming, people would always say how A&A is rather on the light side, so I never got it.

      If I had to pick just two or three games, I think Combat Mission: Black Sea is the single most powerful tool to study tactics. For operational planning, I think Gulf War and CMANO are superb. Especially CMANO, the things you can do with that little game…it is a secret treasure trove!

  2. John

    I helped run a battle of Gettysburg scenario using Kreigspiel at the Brigade Level that was both informative and team building.

    • Which Kriegsspiel ruleset did you use? I’ve been trying to find a decent English translation of one of the earlier versions for a long time – my understanding is that the modern Too Fat Lardies’ version is dumbed-down in the interest of gameplay.

  3. It works.
    The author review is an officer of the tank battalion “August / Pantsir” of the Lugansk separatists. KIA in 2015.
    This man for me has always been an example of a real officer. We knew each other 10 years.
    https://youtu.be/JCwbfayYExw

Leave a Reply